Complaints About Members of the Scottish Tribunals

What do I do if I have a complaint against a Tribunal Member?

Complaints against Tribunal Members

The Lord President has made rules for the investigation and determination of any matters concerning the conduct of members of the Scottish Tribunals: Complaints About the Scottish Tribunals Rules 2018. 

The Judicial Office for Scotland will consider complaints about the personal conduct of legal and ordinary members of Housing and Property Chamber, Tax Chamber, Health and Eduction Chamber, General Regulatory Chamber and the Upper Tribunal for Scotland, but cannot deal with complaints about judicial decisions or the way in which cases have been handled.  The usual way to challenge a decision is to appeal.  If you are considering appealing a judicial decision, we would recommend that you obtain legal advice.  You can obtain such advice from a solicitor or the Citizens Advice Bureau.

If you wish to complain about the personal conduct of a member listed in the Complaint Guidance, whether inside or outside of the hearing, you should complete the above complaint form and return it to:

Judicial Office for Scotland
Parliament House
Edinburgh
EH1 1RQ
or by email: judicialofficeforscotland@scotcourts.gov.uk

The Rules and guidance provide more detail, but you should note that your complaint must be in writing and clearly state:

  • your name and address;
  • the name of the tribunal members or information to enable them to be identified;
  • where appropriate, the hearing venue, and the date of the hearing; and
  • specific details about the grounds of your complaint.

You must include copies of all the documents that you have that you are relying on to support your complaint.

Your complaint should be made as soon as possible and, in any event, no later than 3 months after the incident that you wish to complain about. If your case or appeal is on-going, your complaint may not be considered until your case has concluded but you should still make your complaint in time. The time limit for making a complaint may be extended only in exceptional circumstances. 

Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland

The President of the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland (MHTS) has appointed the Judicial Office for Scotland to handle complaints made against members of MHTS. 

Further information can be found on the MHTS website

If you are unsure about which orgainsation you should complain to, please conact the Judicial Office for Scotland on the above details and a member of staff will be more than willing to assist you. 

See the privacy notice for information about how we handle personal data.

HMA v JEFFREY ASH

Thursday, 19 September, 2013
Sentencing Statements

At the High Court in Edinburgh Lord Pentland sentenced Jeffrey Ash to three years and four months in prison after he pled guilty to culpable homicide and fire raising.

Find out more

HMA v JOSEPH TOWNSLEY

Wednesday, 18 September, 2013
Sentencing Statements

At the High Court in Edinburgh Lady Wise sentenced Joseph Townsley to 7 years imprisonment after he was found guilty of the culpable homicide of Frank Baxter on 8th of May 2012 at Crindledyke Crescent, Newmains, Wishaw.

Find out more

HMA v JAMES FARQUHAR & STEVEN STEWART

Tuesday, 17 September, 2013
Sentencing Statements

At the High Court in Edinburgh Lord Doherty sentenced James Farquhar and Steven Stewart each to 2 years 8 months imprisonment after they pled guilty to the supplying of cannabis resin on 9 October 2012.

Find out more

HMA v JOHN MCNAUGHT MCEWAN

Tuesday, 17 September, 2013
Sentencing Statements

At the High Court in Glasgow Lord Matthews sentenced John McNaught McEwan to life imprisonment with a punishment part of 18 years after he was found guilty of the murder of Eileen Gamble in Glasgow on 26 or 27 July 2012.

Find out more

HMA v KEVIN STOLAREK

Friday, 13 September, 2013
Sentencing Statements

At the High Court in Paisley Lord Burns sentenced Kevin Stolarek to 20 months imprisonment after he pled guilty to rape.

Find out more